PC Game of the Year 2004

[Atebash]

Why, want to change your votes?

[Marcus]

I want to vote Pirates again.. I really feel Pirates! deserves this one, just because remaking it was such a brilliant idea

[Max_Rebo]

I'd like to change my vote too. After the nostalgia wore off, Pirates wasn't all that good. Just the same with new graphics.

I do agree however that Rome was the best Strategy game of the year. I've completed it twice, and started a myriad of games.
Why anyone would consider Codename: Panzers better is beyond me.
I mean, terrain was irrellevant. Tanks and self-propelled artillery and you were nigh invulnerable. Even in cities. You just needed a little repair truck and an ammo carrier and you were set.
Rome on the other hand was good especially if you played nations other than the Romans, which are much easier than the others. A flanking attack here or there often meant the difference between victory and defeat.

[Tobasco]

i wanna vote but i cant dammit!  who the heck heard of that pirate game anyways!?

[Atebash]

The poll is closed, you're late!

Pirates and Half Life 2 share the title!